CollectionDX Network

Queen Emeraldas Movie Version

Comments

7 comments posted
Sounds like you just don't like the design.

I think you're missing a *big big* part of the appeal of this piece: this is the only version of this ship in this large scale other than a model kit, and if you own the other Matsumoto ships in diecast, this is your only option in a similar scale for the QUEEN EMERALDAS. Your only other option before this was a poorly detailed resin version which is more based on the 1998 OVA QUEEN EMERALDAS than the much-more popular GE999 MOVIE this is based on.

you say you're disapointed with the ship, because the other ships were a better value which, based on your review, sounds like you liked them because they had more moving parts. Maybe you just don't like the design- which is fine, but for some people the moving parts and gimicks on this ship don't matter at all, because the ship didn't have any gimicks in the animation.

well this design has exactly 0 big guns, 0 fold out wings, and 0 movable barrels. This is because the *design from the movie* didn't have them. It's hardly fair to knock this toy because it doesn't have the movable parts of the others- it just doesn't need them. It's like getting mad at a Stormtrooper figure and saying he's a rip-off because he doesn't come with a lightsaber and robot arms.

I think that you would be less impressed with the other toys if you handled or owned the amazing DIE-CAST versions of the same ships.

You can't compare the prices though- diecasts for $100+ or these for much less.

I think its also important to note for posterity that these toys are *more* than $15 for most buyers unless they live in HK or caught the HLJ pre-orders. They're on Ebay and at brick & mortar shops for an average of $25-40 a piece at the time of their original release (2007-2008) So keep that in mind- they aren't *really* $15, as most shops are marking them up due to their popularity (especially the yamato).

The Big R's picture
Posted by The Big R on 8 April, 2008 - 09:32
Haven't held this one yet,

Haven't held this one yet, but I'm inclined to suspect the same. I'm sure the toy itself is probably fine, but the design is just lame as can be.


"This must be settled the way nature intended....with a vicious, bloody fight!"
Onyx Blackman
Principal, Flatpoint High

NekroDave's picture
Posted by NekroDave on 8 April, 2008 - 12:23
Hey Big R, You bring up

Hey Big R,
You bring up allot of valid points. I first would like to say that I love the design in concept. In my opinion I feel that Taito could have executed it better. Paint details as well as cool features are both lacking in this model. Again this is only my opinion. You may look at the pictures and want to go out and get it. I just think if you get the other releases, and compare, you will be disappointed.

-Dan

CollectionDX Staff

Shogundan's picture
Posted by Shogundan on 8 April, 2008 - 13:34
I Swear

I swear the Taito series start to growth on me. The price and the quality amaze me!

Berserk's picture
Posted by Berserk on 8 April, 2008 - 20:11
They've done a 999 train and

They've done a 999 train and a Cosmo Zero is next. They do some Harlock props too. All at the same price.

They're great if you find them, it's just tracking them down that makes them a bit rare.

duke togo's picture
Posted by duke togo on 9 April, 2008 - 10:42
Taito’s Queen Emeraldas is still a very bad toy/model

I bought this model ship for $25.00 from HLJ.com (1500yen plus shipping) and I have regretted my purchase decision ever since.

Although this maybe the only big scale Queen Emeraldas ever created, it is still a very bad toy/model.

First of all, there is no reason this is only 30 cm long. The overall shape of Queen Emeraldas is simple enough. The ship’s rear end can easily be made into a detachable part to extend the overall length to 40 cm. But they chose not to do it.

The overall shape is also wrong; the “real” Queen Emeraldas should be longer and narrower. The overall paint applications are too simple and boring.

Take a look here and you will know what I mean.
Zacca PAP Leiji Matsumoto Mecha Collection
This collection comes with two Queen Emeraldas, one true color and one black color. Both versions look much better than this much bigger Taito version. The mini Queen Emeraldas are only 4.5 inches in length, and the guy claimed he paid 100yen for two. 50 yen for one good looking Queen Emeraldas, that was a great deal! I spent 2500yen for one big, fat, ugly Queen Emeraldas, that was a really bad deal!

lukehu's picture
Posted by lukehu on 2 June, 2008 - 02:37
Queen Emeraldas - movie version

I bought this toy from Yahoo Japan via a middleman. The toy is a masterpiece. When considering the amount of anime-accurate detail and the incredibly cheap price, I prefer this to its diecast or plastic model counterparts. A must-have for Leiji Matsumoto-sensei fans.

grendizer1975's picture
Posted by grendizer1975 on 1 October, 2008 - 15:44
 
CollectionDX OtakuDX Love is Pop WTF Toy Chogokin.net